Baltimore City Council
File #: 23-0465    Version: 0 Name: Tree Removal on City Property - Permits and Procedure
Type: Ordinance Status: Enacted
File created: 12/4/2023 In control: Baltimore City Council
On agenda: Final action: 4/24/2024
Enactment #: 24-331
Title: Tree Removal on City Property - Permits and Procedure For the purpose of establishing certain standards and requirements for authorized tree removal along certain rights-of-way; requiring that the Department of Recreation and Parks approve any tree removal on land operated by the Department; specifying the procedure for tree removal mitigation on land operated by the Department of Recreation and Parks; conforming, clarifying, and correcting related provisions; defining certain terms; and generally relating to the removal of trees on certain City properties.
Sponsors: Administration City Council, Mark Conway
Indexes: Permits, Removal, Trees
Attachments: 1. 01 Coversheet 23-0465, 2. 02 Standing Committees List, 3. 03 Synopsis 23-0465, 4. 04 Agency Reports Cover, 5. 04A Office of Sustain, 6. 04B Parks, 7. 04C LAW, 8. 05 Public Comments Cover, 9. 05A, 10. 05B, 11. 05C Suppport Letter - Forestry Board - 23-0465 & 0456.docx-2, 12. 05D Greenspace, 13. 07 1st Reader, 14. XX Agenda 23-0465, 15. XX Final Synopsis 23-0465, 16. XX Hearing Announcement 23-0465, 17. XX Hearing Notes 23-0465, 18. XX Minutes 23-0465, 19. XX Tree Mitigation Bill, 20. Final Synopsis 23-0465 3_20_24, 21. Final Hearing Notes 23-0465 3_20_24, 22. Amendments 3_20_24, 23. 2nd Reader Amendments 24-0465(1)~1st (HET), 24. 23-0465~3rd Reader, 25. 23-0465 Signed, 26. Completed Ordinance 23-0465 24-331
Date Ver.Action ByActionResultAction DetailsMeeting DetailsVideo
5/1/20240 Mayor Signed by Mayor  Action details Meeting details Not available
4/15/20240 Baltimore City Council Approved and Sent to the Mayor  Action details Meeting details Not available
4/8/20240 Baltimore City Council Advanced to 3rd Reader, for Final Passage  Action details Meeting details Not available
4/8/20240 Health, Environment, and Technology Recommended Favorably with Amendment  Action details Meeting details Not available
3/20/20240 Health, Environment, and Technology Recommended Favorably with AmendmentPass Action details Meeting details Not available
3/4/20240 Health, Environment, and Technology Scheduled for a Public Hearing  Action details Meeting details Not available
1/29/20240 Health, Environment, and Technology Scheduled for a Public Hearing  Action details Meeting details Not available
12/18/20230 Health, Environment, and Technology Scheduled for a Public Hearing  Action details Meeting details Not available
12/7/20230 Baltimore City Council Refer to City Solicitor  Action details Meeting details Not available
12/7/20230 Baltimore City Council Refer to Dept. of Finance  Action details Meeting details Not available
12/7/20230 Baltimore City Council Refer to Office of Sustainability  Action details Meeting details Not available
12/7/20230 Baltimore City Council Refer to Dept. of Recreation and Parks  Action details Meeting details Not available
12/4/20230 Baltimore City Council Assigned  Action details Meeting details Not available
12/4/20230 Baltimore City Council Introduced  Action details Meeting details Not available

Explanation: Capitals indicate matter added to existing law.

[Brackets] indicate matter deleted from existing law.

 

                     * Warning: This is an unofficial, introductory copy of the bill.

                     The official copy considered by the City Council is the first reader copy.

                     Introductory*

 

                     City of Baltimore

                     Council Bill          

                                                                                                                                                           

Introduced by: Councilmember Conway

At the request of: The Administration (Department of Recreation and Parks)

                                                                                                                                                           

 

                     A Bill Entitled

 

An Ordinance concerning

title

Tree Removal on City Property - Permits and Procedure

For the purpose of establishing certain standards and requirements for authorized tree removal along certain rights-of-way; requiring that the Department of Recreation and Parks approve any tree removal on land operated by the Department; specifying the procedure for tree removal mitigation on land operated by the Department of Recreation and Parks; conforming, clarifying, and correcting related provisions; defining certain terms; and generally relating to the removal of trees on certain City properties.

body

 

By repealing and re-ordaining, with amendments

Article 7 - Natural Resources

Sections 53-1 to 53-3, 53-5, 53-13, and 53-21

Baltimore City Code

(Edition 2000)

 

By adding

Article 7 - Natural Resources

Sections 53-15 and 53-16

Baltimore City Code

(Edition 2000)

 

Section 1.  Be it ordained by the Mayor and City Council of Baltimore, That the Laws of Baltimore City read as follows:

 

                     Baltimore City Code

 

                     Article 7.  Natural Resources

 

                     Subtitle 53.  Trees along City Streets, etc.

 

§ 53-1.  Definitions.

 

(a)                     In general.

 

In this subtitle, the following terms have the meanings indicated.

 

(b)                     Inch-for-inch replacement.

 

“Inch-for-inch replacement” means the tree removal and replacement standard used by the Department of Recreation and Parks that requires a person to plant a tree or trees with an equal or greater sum diameter, as measured in inches, to the sum diameter of all trees removed by that person, as measured in inches.

 

(c) Permit holder.

 

“Permit holder” means a person to whom the Department of Recreation and Parks has issued a written permit to remove a tree under subsection (c) of

§ 53-15{“Tree Removal - Street”} or § 53-16 {“Tree Removal - Parks”} of this subtitle.

 

(d)                     Root zone.

 

“Root zone” means a circular region, measured outward from a tree’s trunk, that represents the essential area of the tree’s roots that must be maintained or protected for the tree’s survival.

 

(e)                     [(b)]  Tree.

 

The word “trees”, as used in this subtitle, shall not be construed to include shrubs [which] that do not grow higher than 15 feet.

 

§ 53-2.  Jurisdiction of Department of Recreation and Parks.

 

(a)   Regulating planting, etc.

 

The Department of Recreation and Parks, in consultation with the Department of Transportation, is authorized and directed to regulate the planting, protection, [regulating] removal, and controlling of all trees planted and to be planted in the parks or streets[, lanes, or alleys] of Baltimore.

 

(b)  Enforcing protective laws.

 

The statutes and ordinances for the protection of trees in the streets, lanes, or alleys shall be strictly observed by the Departments of Public Works, Transportation, General Services, and Recreation and Parks, as well as all other agencies of the City, within their respective authority.

 

§ 53-3.  Additional duties of Department of Recreation and Parks.

 

It is the duty of the Department of Recreation and Parks:

 

(1)                     to encourage the preservation, culture, and planting of shade and ornamental trees in the City’s parks and streets[, lanes, and alleys];

 

(2)                     to prune, spray, cultivate, and otherwise maintain these trees[, plants, and shrubbery];

 

(3)                     to trim or direct the time and method of trimming these trees[, plants, and shrubbery]; and

 

(4)                     to take all other measures that it considers necessary and reasonable for the control and extermination of insects and other pests and plant diseases that may injuriously affect trees in the City’s parks and streets[, lanes, and alleys].

 

§ 53-5.  Public notice of tree removal.

 

(a)  Notice required.

 

Unless notice is given as required by this section, the City may not:

 

(1)                     remove or destroy a tree along one of the streets[, lanes, alleys, or other public ways] in this City; or

 

(2)                     permit any person to remove or destroy a [a] tree [alone] along one of the streets[, lanes, alleys, or other public ways] in this City.

 

(b)  Form and content.

 

The notice required by § 53-5(a):

 

(1)                     must consist of a durable and legible statement of the intent, affixed to and easily visible on the tree for not less than 5 days immediately preceding the contemplated removal or destruction; and

 

(2)                     must state:

 

(i)                     the reason for the intended removal or destruction of the tree; and

 

(ii)                     the person or persons to whom inquiries or protests thereon may be directed.

 

(c)  Exception for emergency.

 

(1)                     In the event of an emergency situation, such as a fallen tree or some other condition or occurrence requiring an immediate removal or destruction of a tree along one of these public ways, the City or any person it permits may remove or destroy the tree without complying with the foregoing provisions of this section.

 

(2)                     But in this event, the City or the person it permitted promptly shall notify the City Council of the circumstances, conditions, and justification under which the tree was thus removed or destroyed.

§ 53-13.  Permit requirements - Impeding roots.

 

No person may, without first having received a written permit issued by the Department of Transportation, in consultation with the Department of Recreation and Parks, place or maintain upon the ground in any street, lane, or alley, any stone, cement, or other substance or structure that will impede the free entrance of water and air to the roots of any tree without leaving an open space of ground outside the trunk of the tree, in area not less than [16] 32 square feet.

 

§ 53-15.  Tree removal - Street.

 

(a)                     Permit required.

 

(1)                     In general.

 

A person may not remove a tree in or along a public street without first having been issued a written permit to do so by the Department of Recreation and Parks.

 

(2)                     Determination.

 

Within 20 business days of receiving a request for a permit under this section, the Department of Recreation and Parks shall:

 

(i)                     approve, deny, or request additional information regarding  the permit;

 

(ii)                     determine whether mitigation under subsection (d) is required; and

 

      (iii)                     notify the applicant of the Department of Recreation and Parks’ determination.

 

(b)  Removal by licensed experts.

 

Any tree removal permitted under this section must be completed by a licensed tree expert in accordance with Title 5, Subtitle 4, Part III {“Tree Experts”} of the State Natural Resources Article.

 

(c)  Notice.

 

Prior to removing a tree or trees pursuant to a permit issued under this section, the Department of Recreation and Parks must give public notice in the manner described in § 53-5 {“Public notice of tree removal”}.

 

(d)  Mitigation.

 

(1)                     In general.

 

A tree greater than 1 inch diameter at breast height that has been approved by the Department of Recreation and Parks for removal under this section shall be mitigated as provided in this subsection.

 

(2)                     Procedures.

 

If the Department of Recreation and Parks requires that a tree be mitigated under this section, the mitigation shall be an inch-for-inch replacement, to be measured as follows:

 

(i)                     for the removed tree, at the diameter at breast height (4.5 feet off of the ground); and

 

(ii)                     for the replacement tree, at the caliper inch (6 inches off the ground).                                                                                    

 

(3)                     Methods of mitigation.

 

If the Department of Recreation and Parks requires mitigation under this subsection, the permit holder may accomplish the mitigation by:

 

(i)                     planting replacement trees at the site or sites of the removal, as approved by the Department of Recreation and Parks; or

 

(ii)                     if mitigation inches required under this subsection cannot be replanted at the site or sites of removal, planting trees at another site or sites only as approved by the Department of Recreation and Parks.

 

(4)                     Fee-in-lieu of mitigation.

 

If a permit holder cannot accomplish mitigation using a method described in paragraph (2) of this subsection, the permit holder shall pay a fee-in-lieu of mitigation to the Director of Finance in an amount approved by the Board of Estimates.

 

§ 53-16.  Tree removal - Parks.

 

(a)                     Permit required.

 

(1)                     In general.

 

A person may not remove a tree in a public park without first having been issued a written permit to do so by the Department of Recreation and Parks.

 

(2)                     Determination.

 

Within 20 business days of receiving a request for a permit under this section, the Department of Recreation and Parks shall:

 

(i)                     approve, deny, or request more information regarding the permit;

 

(ii)                     determine whether mitigation under subsection (c) is required; and

 

      (iii)                     notify the applicant of the Department of Recreation and Parks’ determination.

(b)                     Removal by licensed experts.

 

Any tree removal permitted under this section must be completed by a licensed tree expert in accordance with Title 5, Subtitle 4, Part III {“Tree Experts”} of the State Natural Resources Article.

 

(c)                     Mitigation.

 

(1)                     In general.

 

A tree approved by the Department of Recreation and Parks for removal under this section shall be mitigated as provided in this subsection if:

 

(i)                     the tree measures 8 inches or greater in diameter at breast height (4.5 feet off the ground); or

 

(ii)                     the tree was deliberately planted and measures 1 inch or greater in diameter.

 

(2)                     Procedures.

 

If the Department of Recreation and Parks requires that a tree be mitigated under this section, the mitigation shall be an inch-for-inch replacement, to be measured as follows:

 

(i)                     for the removed tree, at the diameter at breast height (4.5 feet off of the ground); and

 

(ii)                     for the replacement tree, at the caliper inch (6 inches off the ground).

 

(3)                     Methods of mitigation.

 

If the Department of Recreation and Parks requires mitigation under this subsection, the permit holder may accomplish the mitigation by:

 

(i)                     planting replacement trees at the site or sites of the removal, as approved by the Department of Recreation and Parks; or

 

(ii)                     if mitigation inches required under this subsection cannot be replanted at the site or sites of removal, planting trees at another site or sites only as approved by the Department of Recreation and Parks.

 

(4)                     Fee-in-lieu of mitigation.

 

(i)                     In general.

 

If a permit holder cannot accomplish mitigation using a method described in paragraph (3) of this subsection, the permit holder shall pay a fee-in-lieu of mitigation to the Director of Finance.

 

(ii)                     Amount.

 

The fee-in-lieu of mitigation shall be a standard amount or unit, as approved by the Board of Estimates and updated as necessary.

 

(5)                     Exemptions from mitigation requirements.

 

The Department of Recreation and Parks may exempt a tree from the mitigation requirements of this subsection if the Department of Recreation and Parks determines that the tree is:

 

(i)                     dead;

 

(ii)                     dying;

 

      (iii)                     diseased or otherwise infected and contagious; or

 

     (iv)                     at high risk of death, disease, or failure, as determined by the Baltimore City Forestry Division of the Department of Recreation and Parks.

 

§ 53-21.  Injuring or defacing trees, etc.

 

(a)  Horses or other animals.

 

No person shall fasten any horse or other animal to any tree or shrub in any street, lane, or alley, nor shall any person cause or permit any horse or other animal to stand or be near enough to any tree, plant, or shrub to bite or rub against it or in any manner injure or deface the same.

 

(b)  Attaching items.

 

Nor shall any person attach or place any rope, wire, sign, poster, handbill, or other thing or substance on any tree or shrub in any street, lane, or alley or on any guard or protection of the same.

 

(c)  Injuring, etc., protective devices.

 

Nor shall any person remove, injure, or misuse any guard or device placed or intended to protect any tree, plant, or shrub [now or hereafter] in any park or street[, lane or alley].

 

(d)                     Injuring, etc., tree and root zone.

 

Nor shall any person remove, damage, injure, or otherwise harm any tree or the root zone of a tree beneath the ground.

 

Section 2.  And be it further ordained, That this Ordinance takes effect on the 30th day after the date it is enacted.